• About me and contact
  • Menu Item
RSS  Subscribe:  RSS feed
Luci world
thinking outside the box

Taking advantage of someone’s brand to promote yours.

Posted on January 22, 2011

1



Judging from the title you are probably thinking “what?! Isn’t that called cheating? Isn’t that immoral?”. Yes and no. I will start by writing here two different stories I have personally experienced about missed opportunities that might enlighten your views on this subject.
Case 1 : “Muddy Boots”
There was this programme on television some time ago where some people would go to investors with their business ideas and 1 would be picked to be helped. I remember a couple from the country who sold hamburgers. Their image was very strong: the young couple wearing muddy boots. They managed to pitch successfully to Waitrose. Well done you might think. Oh well…
A couple of years on, walking in one of these food and wine shows in London, I came across the “Muddy boots” stand (or so I thought). I was very delighted to meet a business that had been on TV and so I immediately went to talk them. It went something like this:
“-Hi, you guys were on TV some years ago, I thought that was brilliant!
-Actually, that was not us, it was someone who “stole our idea” and we had to sue* them. They sold hamburgers and we sell sausages.
– I am sorry to hear that, I didn’t remember what they sold, just the “muddy boots”. Oh well, at least it was free advertisement for you, right?.
-Well, we spent a lot of money, creating our reputation and logo for them to steal our idea. We don’t like to be associated with them and that is why they had to pay as compensation and were ot allowed to use “muddy boots” as their logo. 
-I see, well, I thought it was good for you anyway, because I only came here because I thought you were the guys on TV and I didn’t quite remember what you sold…”
This goes to show how powerful an image can be and it struck me as interesting when I learnt that a “copy” business managed to be more successful than its predecessor.  However, instead of using of the fame the “muddy boots”  brand the original company didn’t want to take advantage of its copycat. In fact, he opposed so strongly about the connection it put me off buying his sausages. Am I the only one talking sense here?
Case 2 : A matter of colour
I was volunteering for this charity, which I can’t name for obvious reasons, and they have a beautiful concept “do the work your neighbours would do for you in the old days”. It is (or was) a local charity that worked in a specific area of London helping residents in that area. They did everything from shopping to gardening and dog walking for people who were depressed, lonely, housebound for some reason or just too old to do it for themselves.
The charity was facing financial challenges during these difficult times and I was invited to attend a meeting to discuss the charity’s future. The message was loud and clear: if they didn’t get more money and volunteers the charity would cease to exist in two years.
I suggested a “rebrand”. Changing the  logo, having a better website, looking for more volunteers in a proactive way, engaging with local shops and community (churches etc) going to the local supermarket that sponsors local charities.
New logo designed, website, everything free due to the efforts of lots of designers and friends I have. The reply was:
“We don’t like this colour because it reminds us of the borough. The council has reduced its funding to us so we do not want to be associated with them”.
Fair enough. The only problem was that, the borough is a strong brand. It claims 8 out of 10 residents are satisfied with the borough as a place to live which is better than most of London (2009 survey). This means pretty much all residents there like being associated with the area. In fact, local shops have campaigns saying “we love ……..”  where residents gets discounts. The borough is now ranked 6th/150 top-tier authorities in England.
Despite this proven success the  charity refused  to use “borough colours”  and the idea of rebranding! It still has a unappealing website, fewer volunteers, less money and more work to do.
Of course, this might be a simplistic way of viewing things as we have to take into account the feelings of all those involved. I would not personally like if someone stole my idea to promote itself and ended up being more successful than I am, neither to use the same colours as an organisation that has just reduced my income. However, if it’s business I still believe it might be worth putting feelings aside and benefitting from it. The rest, will be history.
Do you have any similar experiences to share? Have you ever taken advantage of someone’s brand to promote yours? If so please let me know.

* Just for info: the “copycat” hamburger got to keep the name “muddy boots” but the original got to keep the logo that was an image of muddy boots.

Advertisements

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tagged: brading strategy, branding, logo, rebranding, rebranding strategy
Posted in: SMEs tips, Thinking outside the box
Rebranding: Sorry but changing your logo is not going to save your business, in fact, it might even damage it. →
One Response “Taking advantage of someone’s brand to promote yours.” →

  1. Darren Coleman

    February 14, 2011

    Interesting blog…thank you. I remember the couple from that TV show. They were very natural, dare I say ‘middle class’ and fitted with the whole Waitrose brand a treat. I guess that they’ve learnt an important lesson here in terms of stealing someone else’s thunder.

    Your point about visual identity and colour is wonderful. We’ve worked with so many clients that put their emotions before the emotions of their clients. This clouds and colours (no pun intended) peoples’ judgement. If this happens we refer them to another marketing agency as this is a recipe for disaster.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. ( Log Out /  Change )

Cancel

Connecting to %s

Want to follow tweets?

  • RT @criscyborg: #PleaseHelp #SupportMMA fb.me/2P1xQ654g 2 years ago
  • Corruption Scandals in Brazil Reach All the Way to the Top nyti.ms/22qBp6C 2 years ago
Follow @lucirochauk

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2 other followers

Cool blogs & websites

  • Gerenciamento de projeto

Categories

  • Project management tips (4)
  • SMEs tips (4)
  • Thinking outside the box (6)
  • Uncategorized (5)

Archives

  • January 2012
  • November 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
Advertisements
Blog at WordPress.com.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
%d bloggers like this: